Skip to main content

Investments: Future Monte Carlo

Written by Nancy Gates

How Monte Carlo works with Investments: Future

Monte Carlo: Historical Rates vs. the glide-path model

Monte Carlo simulation tests your plan against thousands of possible market paths instead of a single average return. Both versions below report your Chance of Success: the share of simulated paths where your projected savings never drop below $0. They differ in how they create the market returns.

Historical Rates Monte Carlo. Each account has an expected return (the average it should earn per year) and a volatility: how far returns typically swing around that average. Think of it as a "how bumpy" number. For each month of each simulated path, the engine draws a random return for each account from a bell curve built from those two numbers. It does not know an account's mix of stocks, bonds and cash. It treats each account as one fixed risk level for the whole plan. This method runs every account when no path is on, plus any account you have opted out of the glide-path model. Opted-out accounts share the same random draws in each path, so they rise and fall together, like several boats tied to one rope.

Glide-path Monte Carlo. The engine starts one level down, at asset classes such as US large cap, US small cap, international and fixed income. Each asset class has its own expected return and volatility, and a correlation with every other class: how much they tend to move together. US large and small cap move closely, while stocks and bonds often move differently. Each month, the engine draws correlated returns for all asset classes at once, then blends them using the target allocation for your current life stage, for example 70% stocks and 30% bonds. That blended number is the month's return for every account on the glide path. As the primary user moves through life stages tied to their retirement date, the mix steps toward less equity. Within a stage, the mix is reset to target every month, which works like monthly rebalancing with no trades, costs or taxes.

How they are the same

  • Both run thousands of simulated paths through the full plan: income, spending, taxes and withdrawals.

  • Both measure Chance of Success the same way: the share of paths where projected savings never drop below $0.

  • Both hold each account's risk level steady between changes, which works like monthly rebalancing with no trades, costs or taxes.

  • In both, only investment returns are random. Inflation stays fixed at the plan's average.

  • When some accounts are opted out, both run inside one blended simulation, not two separate ones added together.

How they are different

Difference

Historical Rates Monte Carlo

Glide-path Monte Carlo

Return based on

Each account's own expected return and volatility

The target allocation across asset classes

Knows the asset mix

No, one fixed risk level per account

Yes, built up from asset classes

Correlation

Not modeled. Opted-out accounts share the same random draws and move in lockstep

Modeled between asset classes, like real markets

Risk over time

Fixed for the whole plan

Steps down along a glide path by life stage

Which accounts

Opted-out accounts, plus all accounts when no path is on

Eligible accounts that are not opted out

In short, Historical Rates Monte Carlo treats each account as its own bumpy road. The glide-path model treats the whole portfolio as a recipe of ingredients that move together, and the recipe changes as you age.

Did this answer your question?